Siobhan Cotchin’s ‘Top Shelf’ is about a moment of clarity

//
5 mins read

Modern dating can be exhausting; between the disappointing first dates, mismatched expectations and the constant feeling that you should probably give somebody another chance, it’s surprisingly easy to forget what you actually want from a relationship. For Siobhan Cotchin, that realisation became the starting point for her new single, Top Shelf, a song about recognising your own value, protecting your peace and refusing to settle for somebody who doesn’t appreciate what you bring to the table. [1]

“It feels incredible to have this song in the world,” Siobhan expresses to Eat This Music. “I’ve worked extremely hard to create this next chapter and this is the first step into this era. A lot of time, love and joy went into creating this track and I feel very grateful for the whole team that brought it together with me.”

Rather than turning another disappointing dating experience into a heartbreaking confession, Siobhan has approached the subject with humour, confidence and a healthy amount of self-respect. Siobhan explained that the song emerged after a series of unsuccessful dates left her questioning why she was spending so much energy on people who weren’t giving anything meaningful in return. “I feel like I’ve been so focused on actually getting the song out and doing the content and PR side of things that I haven’t had a whole lot of time to look back and appreciate the journey,” Siobhan says. “Thinking about it now though, it was such a joy to create and feels the most authentic I’ve ever been. I really honoured myself and what I truly wanted with this track and all the music to come. I’m really proud of myself for staying true to me.”

That honesty gives her newest song a more relatable foundation than the usual declarations of independence that dominate certain corners of pop music. It’s not necessarily a song about having everything figured out. It’s about recognising that you deserve better, even when you’re still learning how to put that belief into practice. Interestingly, the creative process also encouraged Siobhan to reveal a different side of her personality.

’Top Shelf’ is about a moment of clarity after one too many failed dates and far too long spent on people who didn’t fill her cup (some of them barely managed a splash). “I realised that I deserve so much better and am worth a whole lot more than settling for whoever happens to be in front of me,” Siobhan reveals about the influence of her song. “Like the name suggests: I’m top shelf. The good stuff. The bottle you have to ask the bartender to get the little ladder for. Of course, realising your worth is easier said than done, you can’t just decide it once and be cured, unfortunately. ”

“Believe me, I’ve tried. I’m still on that journey, but this song feels like a step in the right direction. It’s become my personal mantra for surviving modern dating, and honestly, I hope it becomes everyone’s as well when braving the dating world. Let’s face it, being sure of yourself and knowing exactly who you are is hot. If people are intimidated by that, they’re not for you, put them back on the bottom shelf where you found them and keep browsing.”— Siobhan Cotchin

The track was co-written with Francesca De Valence, who encouraged her to approach the lyrics with more humour than she’d previously explored in her songwriting. Siobhan explained that their writing sessions often begin with her sharing stories about her disastrous love life until they discover something worth turning into music. For “Top Shelf,” that meant approaching the lyrics like a conversation between friends after a particularly terrible first date. It’s an effective way to frame the subject because those conversations are rarely straightforward. There’s usually a mixture of frustration, disbelief, laughter and the occasional moment of uncomfortable self-awareness.

And sometimes, the best way to process another disappointing experience is to make fun of how ridiculous the whole situation has become. Siobhan believes that approach allowed her to show listeners a more playful side of herself. “I’m such an unserious person so I feel like I’m showing my listeners a side of me that they only see when I spam post memes on my story or in person,” Siobhan says.

Songwriters can become associated with particular emotional qualities, especially when their previous releases have explored vulnerability or difficult personal experiences. Audiences might connect with those qualities, but they don’t necessarily represent everything about the person creating the music. For Siobhan, “Top Shelf” appears to be an opportunity to broaden that perception without sacrificing the honesty that makes her songwriting personal. She also sees the release as part of a larger creative shift that began with her previous record, Redemption Arc.

Reflecting on the recording process, Siobhan explained that she’s become increasingly comfortable trusting her instincts rather than worrying about how other people might respond. “I’ve learnt that trying to be anything but yourself never works for long,” Siobhan adds.

“I’ve been focusing on my friendships and doing things that fill my cup rather than looking for validation in people that don’t actually know me. I’m my best, most ‘Top Shelf’ self when I listen to my gut and pour my energy into things that fulfil me.” — Siobhan Cotchin

It’s a simple observation, but one that connects directly to the song’s central message. After all, there’s not much difference between changing yourself to impress somebody you’re dating and changing your creative direction because you’re worried about what listeners might think. Both involve seeking approval at the expense of your own instincts. Siobhan seems increasingly determined to avoid either situation.

She described recording “Top Shelf” as one of the most authentic experiences of her career, explaining that she wanted to honour her original vision and allow the song to develop naturally. That confidence also shaped the editing process. Although an additional verse was written, it was eventually removed because it repeated ideas already expressed elsewhere in the song. It’s a small creative decision, but an important one. Knowing when you’ve said enough can be just as valuable as knowing what you want to say.

Away from the studio, Cotchin’s perspective on relationships has changed considerably since she first wrote the track. She explained that she’s become less interested in actively pursuing romantic connections and more focused on the friendships and experiences that make her happy. “To be honest I’ve given up because I’ve realised I’m happiest when I’m protecting my peace from people who don’t match my energy.”

There’s a refreshing practicality to that outlook. The idea of finding happiness through romantic relationships is so deeply embedded in popular culture that choosing to prioritise yourself can sometimes be interpreted as giving up. But there’s another way to look at it. Perhaps recognising that your life is already meaningful without a relationship isn’t an admission of defeat. Perhaps it’s a sign that you’re finally comfortable enough with yourself to stop searching for validation elsewhere. That seems to be the perspective Cotchin is embracing.

And rather than keeping that realisation to herself, she hopes “Top Shelf” can become a reminder for other people navigating similar experiences. “I hope it encourages people to not settle for less and move through the world (particularly the dating realm) with the confidence that they are ‘Top Shelf’,” Siobhan says. As the song also marks the beginning of another busy period for Cotchin and her band.

They’ll celebrate the release with a headline show at Mojos on December 12, joined by Abbe May, The Forever Party and a DJ set from Dolce Diva. Afterwards, Siobhan plans to turn her attention towards preparing her next release, continuing the creative direction she’s been developing. But for now, “Top Shelf” feels like an appropriate statement of where she is personally and artistically.

It’s a song about dating, certainly, but its message extends beyond romantic relationships. There’s something valuable about learning to recognise when an experience, opportunity or relationship isn’t giving you what you need, and having enough confidence to walk away without feeling that you’ve somehow failed. Siobhan isn’t suggesting that everyone should approach life with an inflated sense of self-importance. She’s simply arguing that people should stop treating their own happiness as something negotiable.


[1] — Read the entire interview with Siobhan Cotchin here: Questions for Siobhan Cotchin

Founder of Eat This Music. I spend my spare time sharing delicious new music from Australia and around the world. Since launching Eat This Music, I have covered and interviewed artists ranging from emerging local acts to internationally recognised performers.